India’s rural employment policy is undergoing a major shift. While Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA) or MNREGA has been the backbone of rural wage employment for nearly two decades, the government is now introducing new rural employment and livelihood schemes such as VB-G RAM G (Viksit Bharat-Guarantee for Rozgar and Ajeevika Mission (Gramin). (source)
This article explains the key differences between MGNREGA and VB-G RAM G, the new rural employment guarantee schemes in simple and clear language.
What is MGNREGA?
MGNREGA (Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act) was launched in 2005.
It provides a legal guarantee of 100 days of wage employment every year to rural households.
Key Features of MGNREGA:
- Legal right to employment
- Mainly unskilled manual work
- Focus on wage support during distress
- Work related to water conservation, roads, ponds, etc.
- Payments through Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT)
What is VB-G RAM G, the New Rural Employment Scheme?
VB-G RAM G or G RAM G represents a new generation of rural employment and livelihood-focused schemes aligned with the Viksit Bharat vision.
These schemes aim to:
- Create sustainable rural livelihoods
- Promote skills, enterprises, and asset creation
- Reduce long-term dependency on daily wage labour
Unlike MGNREGA, these are mission-based schemes, not legal guarantees.
MGNREGA vs VB-G RAM G: Detailed Comparison
1. Legal Status
| Aspect | MGNREGA | VB-G RAM G |
|---|---|---|
| Legal Backing | Act of Parliament | Government scheme / mission |
| Job legal Guarantee | 100 days guaranteed | No fixed legal guarantee |
| Minimum number of workdays – per rural household | Minimum number of workdays – 100 | Minimum number of workdays – 125 |
| Financing by Centre and State | more than 90% Centre | 1. For States: 60% Centre + 40% State, 2. For North eastern states – 90:10, 3. For UTs – 100% Centre |
2. Nature of Work
| Aspect | MGNREGA | VB-G RAM G |
|---|---|---|
| Type of Work | Unskilled manual labour | Skilled & semi-skilled jobs |
| Focus | Short-term employment | Long-term livelihood |
| Asset Type | Public utility assets | Income-generating assets |
| Nature of Work | Decided by panchayats based on local needs. | 4 priority areas: 1. Water security, 2. Core rural infrastructure, 3. Livelihood-related assets, and 4. Climate resilience |
3. Wages and Income
| Feature | MGNREGA | VB-G RAM G |
|---|---|---|
| Wage System | Fixed daily wage | Skill-linked income |
| Payment | Bank transfer | Bank transfer + incentives |
| Income Growth | Limited | Higher earning potential |
4. Beneficiaries
| Category | MGNREGA | VB-G RAM G |
|---|---|---|
| Target Group | Rural unskilled workers | Rural youth, women, SHGs |
| Women Participation | Minimum 33% | Women-centric approach |
| Youth Focus | Limited | High priority |
5. Economic Vision
| Aspect | MGNREGA | VB-G RAM G |
|---|---|---|
| Objective | Social security | Rural economic growth |
| Skill Development | Minimal | Strong focus |
| Private Sector Role | Very limited | Encouraged |
Key Differences in Simple Words
- MGNREGA gives daily wages for manual work
- VB-G RAM G focuses on skills, businesses, and income creation
- MGNREGA supports people during financial distress
- New schemes aim for self-reliant villages
Are New Schemes Replacing MGNREGA?
Yes, The Viksit Bharat- G RAM G Bill, 2025 replaces MGNREGA with a new statutory framework aligned with Viksit Bharat 2047.
Which Scheme is Better?
- For immediate wage support → MGNREGA
- For youth employment & entrepreneurship → VB-G RAM G
- For India’s rural future → Both working together
Conclusion
MGNREGA/MNREGA and new rural employment scheme VB-G RAM G serve different but complementary purposes. While MNREGA ensures employment security, the new scheme aims to transform rural India into a hub of skilled workers and entrepreneurs. A balanced approach combining wage protection and livelihood creation is key to achieving Viksit Bharat.
Disclaimer: Kindly refer official website for any inconsistencies in rules, understandings and clarification.
